On the fence with Esther
August 18th, 2011 by Kristi Stephens

Image from visualBiblealive.com
Today I’m going to let you in on a little secret. Something I have wrestled with for years as a female Bible teacher. *Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhh*-
I just don’t know if I like Esther {the historical figure, not the book}.
I go back and forth on this Biblical character. We tend to think of her as a Biblical hero of the faith. The Veggietales version inspires us. We use her as an example of courage and female strength and proper submission and faith. While I agree with most of that, I wonder about the faith piece. Was she really a woman of great faith, or was she fasting and doing the things she did because she was culturally a good Jew? Why is the name of God not mentioned anywhere in the book? Why was she willing to go through the “selection process” {which was more than a singing contest, I’m sure} and not voice any type of moral objection? Why did she hide her nationality? I think of her story in contrast to Daniel, another Jew living in a foreign palace in a hostile land during a time of exile – Daniel most definitely did not hide his nationality, refused to compromise his commitment to God’s law, and risked his life to do what was right rather than take the easy way out. Can we really defend Esther’s actions because her life would have been in jeopardy?
But, then I waver back the other way. Perhaps it is unfair to contrast her with Daniel – she was submitting to Mordecai’s authority and leadership in her life, and we don’t necessarily know if she agreed with him. She does fast and ask Mordecai to call the Jewish people to fast – perhaps prayer was implied?
I tell you, I’m on the fence. A decade ago I would have come down a lot harsher on Esther, but my tone has softened over the years. Yet I’m still not convinced one way or the other. I’ll tell you what I am convinced about, however: Esther isn’t the hero of the story. God is.
The book of Esther is a powerful picture of grace to me. God’s people had turned their backs on Him time and time again. They killed His prophets, rejected His Word, and flagrantly embraced false idols with grotesque practices. God had sent them into exile, where they largely continued to reject His prophets and His Word. By the time the account of Esther begins, Cyrus has allowed the Jews to return to Jerusalem, but some choose to remain where they are. {Again, I wonder why Mordecai and Esther did not return?} And even yet, God is faithful to His people who have not been faithful to Him. Faithful to His people who have turned their backs on Him time and time again. Faithful to His people who remain in a foreign land rather than returning to rebuild. Faithful. He has not forgotten them.
Whether Esther was a faithful follower of God standing courageously in faith for her people or a culturally religious woman simply interested in surviving – it really doesn’t matter as I look at this book. Because either way, God is the real hero. God is the faithful One. It’s all about God.
And as I ponder this I realize… isn’t that what grace really is? The promise that it’s not about me and my story? If my life were written up in a book, I’m not sure I would turn out looking like such a hero. I fail – often. I forget or refuse to believe. My responses and words can be damaging and hurtful. But the message of grace is this: it’s not about my story, but rather about God’s. It’s not about my faithfulness, it’s about God’s. I am not the hero of my story. God is.
Who is the hero of your life story? Self-righteousness wants to make us the centerpiece, to glorify our own goodness and set ourselves up as the example to follow, the hero to emulate. We want to showcase our good deeds and set an example, encouraging others to act like us. People who understand grace want to make God the centerpiece, to glorify His goodness in spite of our failings, to lift Him up as the only source of true goodness, the only hero of our lives. People of grace shine a spotlight on Him, not on themselves, and know that it’s not about our faithfulness, it’s about God’s.
No matter what you think of Esther, it doesn’t really matter. She was a sinner just like you, just like me. And through it all, God was faithful. Through it all, God was the hero once again.

- 6 Comments »
- Posted in One Story












